Updated November 2024
Have you ever considered how much energy it takes to heat water in your home? Water heaters account for about 20% of a home's total energy consumption, making them a significant factor in both your utility bills and environmental impact.
If you're looking to save money and reduce your carbon emissions, it's time to consider a heat pump water heater (HPWH).
Heat pump water heaters are the most energy-efficient water heaters available. Most HPWHs are at least 200 - 300% more efficient than conventional tanks – and can be up to 400% more efficient!
Heat pump water heaters, also known as hybrid water heaters, have gained popularity in the United States for their exceptional energy efficiency. According to the U.S. Department of Energy, they can be two to three times more efficient than conventional water heaters.
This efficiency translates into around $4,000 in savings on utility bills over the lifespan of the appliance. It’s no wonder that heat pump water heaters are so appealing to homeowners looking to upgrade their water heating systems.
Heat pump water heaters (HPWHs) operate on a simple yet ingenious principle: they transfer heat rather than generate it. Here's how they work:
Many also include an electric resistance heater as a backup, which is why they're often called hybrid water heaters. This backup ensures you always have hot water, even in less-than-ideal conditions.
For optimal performance, heat pump water heaters should be installed in an area with a year-round temperature range of 40º–90ºF (4.4º–32.2ºC). They also require about 700-1,000 cubic feet of air space around them to function efficiently.
QuitCarbon is proud to be the only ENERGY STAR® partner providing free assistance with heat pump water heaters and other clean energy upgrades.
ENERGY STAR® notes: "Today’s heat pump technology is far more efficient than previous generations. A low soft humming sound is normal for a heat pump water heater — similar to the sound you hear when a refrigerator turns on."
This video covers some exciting new advances in HPWH technology for 2024:
There are two most common types of heat pump water heaters:
Note: All heat pump water heaters have a storage tank.
Many people believe that tankless or "instant" water heaters are more environmentally friendly, but we strongly recommend against tankless units for environmental, efficiency, and cost reasons.
Here are some of the tradeoffs to consider between a 120V and 240V heat pump water heater.
120V models:
240V models:
Beyond these main options, there are also "split" heat pump water heaters that work well in smaller spaces. The most popular of these is called the Sanden SANCO2 unit, shown below.
Here's a summary of this unit:
The cost of a heat pump water heater (HPWH) consists of upfront expenses and annual operating costs. While the initial investment may be higher, the long-term savings in operating expenses should be taken into account when considering an HPWH purchase.
On average, the total cost of installing a heat pump water heater ranges from $4,000 to $8,000. However, with available rebates and incentives, many customers end up paying significantly less upfront. Considering the lower operating costs, an HPWH often proves to be the most financially sound and sustainable choice when replacing a water heater.
The U.S. Department of Energy estimates that the average heat pump water recommended by QuitCarbon heater costs less than $200 per year to operate. This is significantly lower than the $400-$800 annual cost for conventional gas and electric tank water heaters.
Several factors affect operating costs, including the following.
Various rebates and incentives can significantly reduce the upfront cost of a heat pump water heater:
Check the Database of State Incentives for Renewables & Efficiency (DSIRE) for specific offerings in your area.
When choosing the right heat pump water heater for your home, it's important to consider the brand, size, and specific hot water usage requirements. Here are some factors to keep in mind:
The most common heat pump water heater sizes are 50 gallons, 65 gallons, and 80 gallons. The following sizes work best based on the number of family members:
However, it's essential to consider your specific hot water usage patterns. If you frequently use large amounts of hot water, such as for big baths or when hosting guests, it might be beneficial to size up. This may come with a higher cost upfront but can provide peace of mind.
We also recommend using a Thermostatic Mixing Valve (TMV). This valve allows you to store more hot water than you use since it mixes hot water from the tank with enough cold water to achieve the desired temperature. This feature can reduce hot water consumption by approximately 15% for each shower, dishwasher, or other hot water usage.
First hour rating: Evaluate the "first hour rating" of each HPWH model you are considering. This rating indicates the amount of hot water the unit can provide within the first hour before the tank needs to refill and reheat incoming water.
Estimate maximum hot water usage: Determine the maximum hot water usage you and your family may have within a given hour. Calculate the flow rate of all your hot water end uses, such as showers, faucets, dishwashers, etc. Add up the flow rates for activities that may occur simultaneously.
Larger tanks come with higher costs, so you can also consider reducing hot water usage. That includes running the dishwasher at night and showering in the morning, or shortening shower durations to potentially require a smaller tank.
When comparing heat pump water heaters to other options on the market, here are some key considerations:
|
Feature |
Heat Pump Water Heaters (HPWHs) |
Electric Water Heaters |
Gas Water Heaters |
Tankless Water Heaters |
|
Operating Costs |
Much lower operating costs; saves households $300-400 per year |
Higher operating costs due to lower energy efficiency |
Variable, depending on gas prices; less efficient over time |
Generally lower than conventional heaters but can vary depending on usage patterns |
|
Warranty |
Often comes with longer warranties |
Typically shorter warranties compared to HPWHs |
Varies, but often shorter than HPWHs |
Warranties can be extensive, particularly for premium models |
|
Rebates & Incentives |
Better rebate opportunities, including federal tax credits up to $2,000 |
Limited rebate options |
Fewer rebates available compared to HPWHs |
Some rebates available, though typically less than for HPWHs |
|
Lower Climate Impact |
Emits about 4x fewer emissions than electric models; much lower carbon footprint |
Higher impact due to reliance on electricity, often from non-renewable sources |
Higher carbon emissions due to the use of fossil fuels; less environmentally friendly |
Lower climate impact compared to conventional water heaters, but still higher than HPWHs |
|
Safety and Health |
Eliminates risk of carbon monoxide poisoning as it operates on electricity |
No significant safety concerns related to fuel |
Risk of carbon monoxide poisoning, a major safety concern |
Safer than gas models but requires proper installation to avoid issues like scalding |
|
Immediate Capacity |
Provides ample immediate hot water capacity, suitable for high-demand situations |
Provides consistent capacity but may be less efficient for high-demand situations |
Typically provides consistent capacity, though it depends on the size of the tank |
May struggle with high-demand scenarios unless higher GPM models are installed |
|
Energy Efficiency and Impact |
Highly energy-efficient and environmentally friendly; uses less energy and emits fewer greenhouse gases |
Less energy-efficient; higher energy consumption |
Less energy-efficient; more greenhouse gas emissions due to the combustion of natural gas |
Generally energy-efficient, but climate impact is higher compared to HPWHs due to energy required for instant heating |
Heat pump water heaters require both plumbing and electrical work for installation, so don’t wait for an emergency, such as a broken water heater, to make the switch. It’s perfectly fine and even advisable to replace your gas water heater while it’s still going strong. The steel is valuable and easy to recycle. Plus, the climate benefits of upgrading to an electric water heater far outweigh any benefit of using your gas water heater until it wears out. Still not convinced? Check out our article "Isn’t it wasteful to get rid of my functioning gas water heater?"
Heat pump water heaters represent a significant advancement in home water heating technology. While the upfront costs may be higher, the long-term energy savings, reduced carbon emissions, and available incentives make them an attractive option for many homeowners.
For personalized advice on selecting and installing a heat pump water heater, as well as navigating rebates and incentives, contact QuitCarbon. We can connect you with trusted contractors to ensure a smooth installation process.
By choosing a heat pump water heater, you're not just saving money – you're taking a significant step towards a more comfortable and energy-efficient home.